Friday, November 20, 2026

An Apparent American Herring Gull x Glaucous-winged Gull Hybrid from Wheatley, Ontario with Commentary on Modern Identification Challenges for Field Ornithologists

 

Sharing something that was published in the Ontario Birds journal, during my ill-fated attempt to bring some "field ornithology" back to the Ontario Field Ornithologists... 

Normally I would post a link to the article, but OFO has recently taken the short-sighted approach of pay-walling the most recent issues... Yes, it will be visible online a year after it comes out.. And yes, you can now get a "free" membership with OFO - but no one is going to sign up just to read a note on a hybrid gull. 

Instead, I'm copying and pasting this into a blog... 

Another small (sad) example of stagnation - due to the board's refusal to modernize - which has pushed our most active birders into "other" spaces (blogs, discord groups), ultimately splitting the community a little bit more and reducing the core "purpose" of OFO itself. 

But I digress.. 

-----


An Apparent American Herring Gull x Glaucous-winged Gull Hybrid from Wheatley, Ontario with Commentary on Modern Identification Challenges for Field Ornithologists 

Holden, B.R., 2026. An apparent American Herring Gull x Glaucous-winged Gull hybrid at Wheatley, Ontario with commentary on modern identification challenges for field ornithologists. Ontario Birds 44(1):9-17


On 26 April 2022, I observed an unusual large gull (Larus sp.) at Wheatley Harbour in Chatham-Kent County, Ontario. I had spent the morning a short distance to the west, at the end of Zion Road where it meets Lake Erie, watching for potential “reverse migrants”: birds retreating south following a strong shift from seasonally warm air to seasonally cool air. This dynamic juxtaposition of weather may produce notable migratory movements or vagrancy locally and can be more climatologically likely at this time of year. That is to say, while you are never quite sure what you might see during a day of birding, I was not entirely surprised to spot birds like Baltimore Oriole (Icterus galbula), Cape May Warbler (Setophaga tigrine), and Northern Parula (Setophaga americana) flying down the shoreline while an adult Thayer’s Iceland Gull (L. glaucoides thayeri) and an adult American Herring Gull (L. smithsonianus) x Glaucous Gull (L. hyperboreus) hybrid (aka “Nelson’s” Gull) were foraging behind active fishing operations offshore (see Holden 2022a). It was the observations of these arctic gulls that encouraged me to visit Wheatley Harbour after the morning flight movement had waned.


Figure 1. Apparent near-adult Glaucous-winged Gull x American Herring Gull hybrid (i.e., Cook Inlet Gull) from Wheatley, Ontario on April 26, 2022. Photo by Brandon Holden. 


The subject gull was present on the offshore rock pile near the mouth of the harbour upon arrival and initially appeared to be in a full adult plumage (Holden 2022b, see Figure 1). It was recognizable as a “white-winged” gull, and briefly made me consider the likelihood it was one of the recently observed gulls to the east (i.e., the adult Thayer’s Gull or the adult Nelson’s Gull); however, it was quickly apparent that the size and structure recalled a Glaucous-winged type Gull (L. glaucescens) due to its unique "west coast" proportions and bulk. The dark gray primaries were significantly wrong for this species which indicated it was likely a hybrid. The mantle shade initially appeared slightly darker than nearby American Herring, but at other times appeared similar. Some signs of immaturity later became apparent, such as mottling on the underwing, which suggested a “4th cycle” plumage (i.e., a near-adult) which coincidentally is somewhat frequently shown by pure Glaucous-winged Gulls (pers. obs).

In lieu of a more traditional written description, I will present an account of the identification process supplemented with some of the available media. 

Preliminary Study

After securing my first flight images of the bird, I reviewed one image of the primary pattern, which initially set my identification process astray (see Figure 2). This one image showed the dark primary markings extending up to the base of the feathers from P10 through P7, recalling the primary pattern shown by Western Gull (L. occidentalis). This made for an initial assumption that the bird may be a hybrid between Western Gull and Glaucous-winged Gull (i.e., an “Olympic Gull”). 


Figure 2. Apparent near-adult Glaucous-winged x American Herring Gull hybrid from Wheatley, Ontario on April 26, 2022. Photo by Brandon Holden. Note how in this angle, there appears to be extensive and high reaching dark markings on the outer primaries (i.e., P10 through P7) which may recall the pattern shown by Western Gull. 


It wasn’t until later, with the full suite of images available to review on a computer, that it became apparent that the black primary markings were largely concentrated on the outer webs of each feather (see Figures 3 and 4) along with a “string of pearls” (i.e., white crescents above the black terminal band on the outer primaries). This was therefore not supportive of Western Gull as the other potential parent species but also seemed to be at odds with perhaps the most likely or expected explanation, a Glaucous-winged Gull x American Herring Gull hybrid (i.e., a “Cook Inlet Gull”). I have been fortunate to observe thousands of individuals of this hybrid combination during nearshore marine surveys around Prince Rupert, British Columbia and I could not recall observing such an extreme primary pattern as shown by the subject bird (see Figure 5). 



Figures 3 and 4. Apparent near-adult Glaucous-winged Gull x American Herring Gull from Wheatley, Ontario on Apr 26, 2022. Photo by Brandon Holden. Note the primary pattern, with dark gray to blackish markings extending down the outer webs of the outer primaries, along with large primary mirrors and a “string of pearls” (white markings above the dark terminal band) on the 5th through 8th primary. Darker markings on the underwing are also visible, indicating a near-adult plumage. 



Figure 5. Adult Glaucous-winged Gull x American Herring Gull from offshore Prince Rupert, British Columbia on December 9, 2013. Photo by Brandon Holden. Note the reduced white in the outer primary pattern. 


The heavy structure of the bird, the extensive string of pearls, and the "venetian blind" effect to the primary markings provided some reason to consider a Glaucous-winged Gull hybrid with Slaty-backed Gull (L. schistisagus), also known as the “Commander Gull”. While this combination is presumably very rare anywhere in North America, some media available in the Macaulay Library and on iNaturalist.org appeared to look surprisingly similar to the subject bird (see Figure 6). Yet, the combination of a reasonably pale mantle on the Wheatley bird and the extreme unlikeliness of a Commander Gull reaching the Great Lakes called for a greater effort in my research. 



Figure 6. Apparent adult Glaucous-winged Gull x Slaty-backed Gull hybrid (i.e., Commander Gull) from Hokkaido, Japan on 5 February 2020. Photo by Morten Ross via iNaturalst.org, observation number 73984591. 

Commander Gull vs. Cook Inlet Gull

Despite the primary pattern, I still felt that a Cook Inlet Gull may be a reasonable explanation for the appearance of the subject bird. Hybrids from the Gulf of Alaska, while common in their home range, may not be an ideal source population for the potential occurrence of this hybrid in Ontario. I speculated that a Glaucous-winged Gull at the northern or northeastern limits of the species range may well hybridize with a more northerly or arctic nesting American Herring Gull, each showing subtle regional variation when compared to the more commonly observed hybrids originating further south or west. They may also be more likely to reach the Great Lakes due to their longer overland migration and potential for prevailing fall and winter winds to push them south and east. 

A more focused search of available media quickly added support to this theory. A Cook Inlet Gull documented by Cameron Eckert from Whitehorse, Yukon on 11 Apr 2016 showed a similar venetian blind pattern to the dark primary markings combined with the white “string of pearls” (see Figure 7) among other notable individuals. Interestingly, a vagrant Glaucous-winged Gull from Illinois in January 2024 showed a similar underlying primary pattern, with the venetian blind distribution and extensive string-of-pearls  (see Figure 8). This pattern would again seem extreme when compared to apparently “pure” Glaucous-winged Gulls from the Gulf of Alaska (see Figure 9). 


Figure 7. Adult Glaucous-winged Gull x American Herring Gull from Whitehorse, Yukon on 11 April 2016. Photo by Cameron Eckert. Note the extensive white markings in the outer primary pattern. 


Figure 8. Adult Glaucous-winged Gull from Lake County, Illinois on 22 January 2024. Photo by Woody Goss. Note the “string of pearls” pattern showing in the outer primaries. 



Figure 9. Adult Glaucous-winged Gull from offshore Prince Rupert, British Columbia on December 4, 2013. Photo by Brandon Holden. 


While confidently identifying hybrid gulls may ultimately be an exercise in guesswork and assumptions, it felt prudent to now consider the identification of the Wheatley bird as a Glaucous-winged x American Herring Gull, the Cook Inlet Gull, despite not strongly resembling the widespread examples of this hybrid from the Gulf of Alaska. Further, any potential occurrence of Commander Gull locally might be expected show a mantle tone distinctly darker than an American Herring Gull. 

Discussion

The involvement of Glaucous-winged Gull as a parent of the subject bird was judged mainly from its general size and shape; however, it is very hard to adequately capture these traits in photos or to clearly describe them in text. Early commentary from other gull enthusiasts expressed doubt that a more common species, such as a “Thayer’s” Iceland Gull, could be confidently eliminated. I later noticed that I had fortuitously captured several photos of the subject bird in flight in close proximity to an American Herring Gull, which provides a clear point of reference to judge size and shape (see Figures 10, 11, and 12). This supported my field impression, but it also highlighted what I perceive to be a growing problem in bird study: a fortunate moment was needed to make the bird adequately documentable to external experts who focus only on photographic study. The account of an experienced field observer is often ignored, and instead the record may only “survive” if a lucky situation arises when obtaining media documentation. While higher quality media is always valuable, expecting all observations to occur with ideal angles, lighting, or postures - to validate an unusual sighting - feels like an unreasonable expectation that would ultimately hamper future study and learning. 





Figures 10, 11 and 12. Apparent near-adult Glaucous-winged Gull x American Herring Gull hybrid, in close proximity to a third cycle American Herring Gull, from Wheatley, Ontario on 26 April 2022. Photos by Brandon Holden. Note the broad wings and bulky proportions of the hybrid gull in direct comparison to the American Herring Gull.  



Much of my research regarding the Wheatley bird focused on what I perceived to be an atypical expression in the primary pattern. Popular reference material, such as Gulls of the Americas (Howell and Dunn 2007) or The Gull Guide (Ayyash 2024), may have ultimately shed light on the potential variability of Cook Inlet hybrids, yet there are limits to how much information can be presented in the text, and how many potential variations can be shown as printed media. These guides show a combined 59 images of Glaucous-winged x American Herring Gull hybrids, representing both perched and flight images of all age classes. While the Macaulay Library does not apply the same vetting standards as formal publications, and would require more caution as a reference source, there are over seven thousand reference photos of this hybrid available for study (eBird 2026). Therefore, I propose that while it is important to utilize expert opinion and popular reference materials when opportunity arises, they should not immediately override the research conducted by keen birders regarding an atypical bird observation.  


Conclusion

While the identity of this gull may be of interest to those engaged in bird study, I also hope this article works to encourage observers to push analytical boundaries, question established norms and undertake independent research when presented with a challenging observation. I believe that the identification of some unusual or vagrant birds will improve with a broader recognition that regional variation can influence plumage variation and/or molt timing. Rigid expectations, based on a specific reference population or a limited set of published images, risk obscuring atypical yet legitimate expressions of variation. Expert opinions, while valid, may be overly cautious, quick to dismiss, or rush judgement on images alone without appreciating observer input. This may inadvertently stifle meaningful discussion or even discourage further study. As a result, valid questions or interesting observations may be lost, not because they lack merit, but because they challenge familiar thinking or require notably more effort by eBird reviewers or bird records committees to fully evaluate. 

This individual represents a rare occurrence of an apparent American Herring Gull x Glaucous-winged Gull hybrid in Ontario, well east of the typical hybrid zone in western North America. It is also worth noting that there are previous reports of putative Glaucous-winged Gull x American Herring Gull hybrids from Ontario and nearby US states but given that hybrid gulls do not “count” on the lists of competitive birders, there is significantly less interest in their identification and these records may also have received less scrutiny for their validation. It is hoped that this article encourages others to undertake and enjoy detailed study of gulls.



Citations 

Ayyash, A. 2024. The Gull Guide: North America. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ. 528 pp. 

eBird. 2026. The Macaulay Library media search for Glaucous-winged Gull x American Herring Gull hybrids. Accessed by Brandon Holden on 5 February 2026. 

Holden, 2022a. eBird checklist S108170512, accessed 3 February 2026. https://ebird.org/checklist/S108170512  

Holden, 2022b. eBird checklist S108170016, accessed 3 February 2026. https://ebird.org/checklist/S108170016 

Howell, S.N.G. and J. Dunn. 2007. Gulls of the Americas. Houghton, New York, New York. 516 pp.


Friday, November 13, 2026

But what if there was a Prothonotary Warbler in Moosonee

 

This was yelled at me a good 3-4 times during my first presentation on some ideas of how to improve the OBRC (which is not public)... I'm not sure any of my response was actually processed, but I tried... 

To be honest, I know my response didn't really sink in, because 4-5 other people brought it up to me, even months afterwards... ("He kept saying, but what if there was a Prothonotary Warbler in Moosonee")... 


For context - Ontario is a big place. When our BRC was formed, the province was split into 2 review zones, the "North" and the "South" ... Eventually the north was split again, leaving 3 review areas, and a goofy looking provincial list: 


For further context, my proposal was: just have a single province-wide review list for the OBRC annual report. The rarest of the rare, anywhere in Ontario. Stop accepting Pectoral Sandpipers as Sharp-tailed Sandpipers, stop accepting Peregrine Falcons as Mississippi Kites, stop providing random pointless stats in the annual report, stop rejecting anything slightly difficult or interesting. 

Spend more time on the most interesting bird records. Put the effort in and provide valuable insights in the annual report. Something the community could learn from. 

But what if a Prothonotary Warbler showed up in Moosonee?! It was a rebuttal that had a simple premise. There would be some pretty cool bird observations, someday, that would fall through the cracks and not appear in the annual report. 

So let's get into it. 




To start, it wasn't a great example. Prothonotary Warbler has a well documented history of northward wandering, with multiple records on James Bay in Ontario. There are records from Labrador. Records from backyard bird baths in north-central Quebec. 

A Cerulean Warbler in Moosonee would be way more interesting. Alas, here's what my plan would have done to address this. 

1. The record isn't "lost" by missing out on the annual report. In 1981, a cool observation would become functionally inaccessible if it wasn't published (which is what made a BRC annual report so great). In 2026, it can appear in peer-reviewed online databases within seconds, including photos. 

2. The sighting can still get published. It doesn't take 7 experts, 3 rounds of voting, and 13+ months of elapsed time to reach our provincial journal. If that Cerulean Warbler showed up in Moosonee, the updated BRC process would have encouraged members to work with observers to proactively get the sighting published as a stand alone note. A full piece on a specific bird observation, even if it's a fairly mundane encounter, is WAY more information than what appears in an OBRC annual report. It also opens the door for further discussion or learning, such as the added commentary in the linked OROR piece. 

3. As hinted earlier, the OBRC (or other BRC's) aren't exactly firing on all cylinders when it comes to accepting or rejecting observations that are ACTUALLY notable on that higher, province-wide level...  




Overall, seeing the force of the "all change is bad" crowd was one heck of a learning experience. People in favour of the change would often say "we just need to find a way to better explain it to them". 

In reality, there seemed to be no amount of logic, discussion, reasoning, or time that could really convince a "change is bad" person into thinking that change, might not be all that bad. 

Likewise, some people just seemed incapable of picturing how a new process would work, no matter how many times or ways it was explained. Aphantasia, but for new ideas or concepts, I guess? 



The sad part is, smaller journals seem to be dying out (see Michigan, and now Illinois to some degree). I haven't talked to anyone in years who cares that much about North American Birds. I hoped to get our own Ontario Birds journal off of the ventilator with this approach, but the lack of support from the OBRC and the OFO board to improve, makes it seem like an impossible task. 


I'm not sure writing blog posts will help either? But it's a slightly cathartic 10 minutes to put this in writing. Maybe someday, somehow, the idea that "doing something of value again" might catch hold, vs. the "change is bad" or "everything has to stay the same, because nostalgia" response that has taken hold. 


Monday, November 9, 2026

Pelee Jaunt - Nov 3, 2026

 
Birds! 


I drove down late on Nov 2nd and spent a small amount of time "night birding" - but I didn't see anything, and decided to sleep. 

Nov 3rd was fun at Point Pelee. I needed to remind myself why there are so few notable rare passerine records in fall from the tip itself - and it worked. Some potential reasons: 

  • Too many gulls and raptors flying aboot
  • Too windy (in particular, the dynamics between the weather systems & the water temperature)
  • A change in the trigger for vagrancy in the first place (i.e., different ages and life stages of any potential rares)
Nonetheless - good birding was had. Insects also put on a show with 9 species of Leps and 6 species of Odes. Details here: https://ebird.org/checklist/S407998552





The real action kicked off at night. I was very tempted to see what would happen with nocturnal bird movement and the warm temperatures. It barely went below 19 C all night! Would it be possible to detect late or "wrong way" migrants? 

I split the night into two parts - starting with a 3 hour watch just as it was getting dark: https://ebird.org/checklist/S407998401

In a way, the weirdness I had hoped for actually happened. In this first session, only 11 songbirds in total were observed, yet one was identifiable as a Red-eyed Vireo (!! - thanks to the magic of digital photography). Interestingly, I didn't hear a single NFC during this watch. The checklist may look rather dull at face value, but seeing birds at night has been unimaginably exciting. The flock of Ring-necked Ducks was really neat - and it inspired me to take some photos and a few seconds of uneventful video... 




After a short sleep, I was back out around ~3:20 am for another round: https://ebird.org/checklist/S407998356

Unlike the early evening hours, I finally heard some NFC's ... Siskins! There are always some tantalizing birds that go unidentified with these watches. Thankfully the Short-eared Owl hung around long enough for me to get some really good looks and visually confirm the ID. I've seen no shortage of these birds over the years - breeders, wintering birds, birds travelling to and from roosts, birds flying way out over the lake during wicked storms...... but the flight style of this bird was unlike any previously. Active nocturnal migration.  So cool! 

I had the ability to bird the rest of the day - but with my biggest curiosity-itch fully scratched - I ended up heading for home pretty soon thereafter. 
 

Thursday, November 5, 2026

Golden-Plover ID - Point Pelee - early Oct 2026

 

This is about a previously mentioned sleep-deprived encounter with an adult Golden-Plover. While I'm pretty sure it's an American Golden-Plover, I felt like the though process was worth sharing. 

Photos by Max Segler 



Step #1 in finding an interesting bird: notice something seems "different". There was a flock of juv Am. Golden-Plover flying around the beach for a period of time, but this bird never joined them. 



Some listed features of Pacific Golden-Plover include a long bill and long legs. Per points #1 and 2 above, from a distance, I thought they looked pretty long. The distribution of white and black on the belly, while heavily in molt, sure didn't look *wrong* for Pacific Golden-Plover either (the broad white band, #3). 

I'll admit, I wasn't terribly excited, but it was worthy of further investigation. 



If point blank views were possible, I would have been able to see more critical details. Per above, the red lines show the length of the tertials vs. the tail tip. In Pacific, they're nearly the same. In American, the tertial tips are much closer to the body than the tail tip. The amount of primary tips visible (blue lines) averages a shorter/smaller amount visible. Combine these features and it makes for a unique "back end". I also feel like fresh Pacific Golden-Plovers have a slightly different hue of "gold" on fresh feathers vs. American (yellow line) - but this is likely far less definitive. 

I held out hoping for a flush - perhaps some photos, and a chance to look at those feet. Pacific Golden-Plovers are reported to have their toes extend past the tail tip, whereas American do not. 



While I didn't get any more pictures of my own, Max did (per above), and I watched the bird fly in my scope. 

The toes peek past the tail tip. Honestly, it's not much different than the one flight photo of the first Ontario record. Alas, it's also not that much different than other reference media of American Golden-Plovers... Turns out those toes might be one of those features where there is overlap between the species, at least depending on photo angle / posture etc. Some images of Pacific really do show crazy long toes, which is interesting, right up until you have a bird like this! Ahh! 


We never did get a clear view of the critical "back end" details. What is visible in the photos suggests American Golden-Plover to me. It seems the tertials and tail tips are well offset (red), and it does look like there is a lot of primary tip showing (blue). 

No matter what, it was another fun chance for some solid bird study. 

While I'm not a fan of just reiterating known ID criteria, I do think there is some value in sharing field experiences. Even more so, I can't stress how much easier it is to really learn and appreciate these published ID features, when you have a real life bird to look at. Can you *see* how long the toes are in flight? Or do you need pictures in order to tell? ... How visible are the tertials & tail tip at a distance? How much overlap, or how reliable, are some of these published field marks? 



Monday, November 2, 2026

Bland El Nino Birding - Oct 30, 2026

 

I convinced myself to get out in the field again... I'm privileged to be able adapt my schedule to good birding weather & good birding seasons... Sure, the weather wasn't amazing... But hopefully it would be "good enough"? 

Maybe a morning flight watch at Rondeau would be enough to get my nemesis Townsend's Solitaire in Ontario? 

https://ebird.org/checklist/S406678455

It wasn't. 


I then teamed up with some other talented birders for a hawk watch just east of Rondeau. Things were promising early, including some nice Red-shouldered Hawks and good looks at a Golden Eagle - but I eventually lost focus and left... 

The birding (both locations) really was fun - still filled with awesome sights to see... I'm just itching for something more unusual or remarkable to happen weather wise... 

-----

The night before (Oct 29) - I recorded this quick video on my impressions of how this "super" El Nino fall has been going so far. Check it out, if you're interested! 


Saturday, October 31, 2026

More SE Lake Huron - Oct 27 & Oct 28, 2026

 


Oct 27 - ESE wind, clear skies, cool overnight temps (2C), seasonally strong migration on radar... 

https://ebird.org/checklist/S405881198

Highlights: 

1 Ross's Goose 
11 Cackling Goose 
70 Brant 
1 Little Gull 
48 Common Loon
1 Peregrine Falcon 
3000 American Robin 
350 Cedar Waxwing
90 Purple Finch 
440 Pine Siskin 
1 Fox Sparrow
~25,000 Blackbirds 

The Ross's Goose flew south offshore inside a flock of Cackling Geese. It would have been pretty easy to assume it was a Snow Goose inside a flock of Canada's - but they'll have to be sneakier if they want to get past this sneaki boi. 

The Brant were really perplexing. Way up high and inland - not where you expect to see Brant in Huron County. Again - there was no hiding their true identities. Bunching and unbunching as they do. More compact that Cackling Goose... At a basic level, the GISS of Cackling Goose reminds me of Northern Pintail ... Brant is more like a Mallard. A big flock - the day after James Bay emptied of birds... I wouldn't have minded a closer look, but in reality, I was super excited to spot them and be aware of the unusual nature of the sighting. 

An adult Little Gull offshore is reasonably expected this time of year, but still nice. Juv Peregrine Falcon was nice. 

A point of contrast to the next day. Lots of AMRO and blackbirds, moderate finch flight. Generally speaking, it felt like a huge number of birds migrating - but the flight lines were fanned out, with some birds pushing inland - reducing concentration. Blue skies make it slightly harder to spot birds as well. 


Oct 28 - SE wind, cloudier, warmer overnight (9C), virtually no migration on radar. 

https://ebird.org/checklist/S406136887

Highlights: 

300 American Robin 
550 Cedar Waxwing 
460 Purple Finch 
4 White-winged Crossbill
1360 Pine Siskin 
~7,000 Blackbirds 

I suspect the difference in Geese had to do with the conditions on James Bay on Oct 26 - not really the local conditions. 

The reduction in American Robin and Blackbirds was quite interesting to me. The flight lines were more concentrated. I suspect a significantly reduced flight happened, but better concentration along the shoreline, due to a slight tweak in wind direction. 

For whatever reason, irruptive finches (and waxwings) seem to enjoy a warm headwind - and the slight shift worked wonders to concentrate a solid flight right overhead. There is a real difference in behaviour & flight conditions when compared to our typical annual diurnal migrants. 


Nothing groundbreaking - but it was fun setup to compare each day. It was actually the opposite from a week earlier - where the cool day with a large radar movement had SE winds at dawn, but the next warmer / slower day shifted more east. It really helps highlight that the concentrating wind had a greater effect on the finches, whereas the radar movement was corelated to the larger flights of Robins & Blackbirds. 

Wednesday, October 28, 2026

How it could be. Hybrid Warbler (?) edition.

 

Have you ever heard that "that everything is actually fine, and that there is no evidence to suggest that everything isn't already perfect" when it comes to bird record keeping? Perhaps you've heard that local bird journals are totally fine. They're not shutting down. Not to mention how the ones that are still operating are not lacking submissions. (Spoiler alert, they are - all this despite the number of exciting bird observations increasing dramatically thanks to the large number of birders today, many armed with digital cameras). 




In reality - everything literally is fine. You and I can just go birding and enjoy ourselves (!) ... and the SQPS can hand each other awards like a celebratory game of hot potato. There is no need to interact. Honestly, I know I'm one of the very few weirdo's who even thinks about this stuff. 

Alas, there were numerous calls to "demonstrate a problem" when proposing the OBRC enter the new millennium... and perhaps some other poor soul may try to modernize the process again - either in Ontario or beyond - so maybe highlighting some examples might someday be of help... to someone... 


My inspiration starts with a really interesting warbler photo (see below). It was "forwarded" by Jacob McLaren to the GLBSG discord group to the "hybrids" channel. Along with two messages, one saying "This bird has been a puzzler. It seems to have traits of NAWA and TEWA." and a second noting it was taken at Hawk Cliff in Ontario. 

I want to make it clear - I don't know who took the picture, and this post isn't about that person (i.e., the observer / photographer). It isn't about the bird sighting itself or this specific photo. The image and query is a useful framing device to show that my local BRC, and presumably others, have forgotten one of their core reasons for existing. 

Straight from the OBRC "bylaws". Section 2.0 Purpose:

  • 2.6. Establish standards of observation and reporting, against which field observers may compare their own technique. 


Establish standards. 

Since the OBRC process is still frozen in 1999, there are no standards around digital photography. Actual examples of how single photos could be misleading. A demonstration of how multiple images, angles and lighting can increase confidence in visible traits. 

A BRC should strive to publish valuable sightings with commentary or clear examples of what was required in order to meet that threshold. Even rejected records would have significant value to share with the community. A demonstration of the scientific value images can provide. 

While the single available image is highly suggestive of a Tennessee x Nashville Warbler hybrid, established precedent highlights how a single image, particularly in the absence of corresponding field notes, fails to provide a level of confidence required for acceptance. This is due to past examples demonstrating how a single image may misrepresent field marks. Modern AI sharpening tools may be inadvertently applied to images, further obscuring genuine field marks - a growing problem with record keeping. 

Likewise, a full note or article could be encouraged for a notable sighting to support the local journal - assuming the documentation does fall into place. Even if the bird was a hybrid, and didn't count on a list. There are still things that can be learned, or even publishing simply as an example (i.e., a demonstration of an established standard) of what "field ornithology" can look like for an amateur enthusiast.  Honestly, it's not just photos. The "standards" that a BRC promotes for how to document an interesting bird are going to be able to collect Old Age Security before long... This particular warbler just convinced me to start typing... 

Things have been stagnant for so long, it is difficult to see how the old BRC process could gradually adapt to the world today. It's a shame, but here we are. 



Monday, October 26, 2026

SE Lake Huron on a SE Wind - Oct 21, 2026

 
Magic! 



It's possible I birded a bit too hard in Aug & Sep... I think the El Nino fueled lack of "code red" birding weather may also be playing a role. Long story short, I haven't been out and about as much recently. Save for a touch of night birding. Some decent days recently have also happened to line up with other commitments. 

Some moderately OK weather was enough to break the streak. Oct 21, 2026. A few hours on a nice SE wind after a decent movement on radar. I did forget my bins, but what can you do. 

The burbs.. or at least, the migratory species in flight are listed below... I clicked PUFI, CEDW and AMRO x10 to inform my other estimates: 

Mourning Dove  7
Common Loon  3
Double-crested Cormorant  1
Turkey Vulture  13
Sharp-shinned Hawk  41
Cooper's Hawk  1
Red-tailed Hawk  1
Yellow-bellied Sapsucker  1     
Northern Flicker  5
American Kestrel  1
Merlin  1
Blue Jay  200
American Crow  225 
Horned Lark  30
Ruby-crowned Kinglet  1
Golden-crowned Kinglet  3
Red-breasted Nuthatch  6
Blue-gray Gnatcatcher  1     
European Starling  12000    
Eastern Bluebird  11
American Robin  1740     
Cedar Waxwing  240     
American Pipit  80
House Finch  45     
Purple Finch  480    
White-winged Crossbill  17    
Pine Siskin  520    
American Goldfinch  350
Lapland Longspur  10
Chipping Sparrow  3
Dark-eyed Junco  20
White-throated Sparrow  3
Red-winged Blackbird  5000
Brown-headed Cowbird  100
Rusty Blackbird  3500     
Common Grackle  7500
blackbird sp.  2500  
Orange-crowned Warbler  1     
Yellow-rumped Warbler  50




Some birders chase vagrants... Some try for high counts... I like to find the right combo of weather & geography that makes me say "wow, that was great!" when it's all said and done. Non-stop birds for ~2 hrs. The flight lines were good. The light was good. Magic! 

The Blue-gray Gnatcatcher was interesting. It lingered for a few minute before launching high & going south. It didn't have much of a tail. Are birds like this simply "late"? Due to injury or something? Did it get blown north at some point? 

The 3500 RUBL & 1740 AMRO were fun counts for the fall. An Orange-crowned Warbler in flight was a nice surprise. 

Finches are really up to something as well. The ~480 PUFI was delightful. Small numbers of WWCR is an unusual treat around here. Siskins are always great. No RECR yet, but I have to assume they're on route given the massive counts along Lake Superior. 


I tried again on the 23rd. Comparable species. A fun kickoff of a hawk flight (but I had to leave). The wind was slightly different. There was more of a chill in the air. The flight lines were more spread out, with birds pushing inland. My only WWCR was at dawn - I suspect they were flying - just not as close to the shoreline!

So now what?! I'll probably be tempted to just stay home, bird the yard, and garden given the beautiful weather... but I've also got Townsend's Solitaire on the brain, as a bit of a nemesis bird... Time will tell what happens. Models are hinting at a stormier pattern shift in November. Not super November stormy as far as I can tell (not yet, at least) - but a lot more stormy than this 20C, Sunny and no wind pattern. 


Thursday, October 22, 2026

If you love something, set it free. Why bird records committees need to evolve.

 
Another (not) amusing situation - I wrote this as a commentary for the Ontario Birds journal (back in June) - to help explain the need for our BRC to adapt with the times. It wasn't published. 

----

The Ontario Bird Records Committee (OBRC) was established in 1981 to replace the Ontario Ornithological Records Committee (OORC), which at that time was no longer meeting the needs of the active field ornithologists of the era. 

At its inception, the OBRC was a cutting-edge way to collect, archive and disseminate knowledge. It provided a centralized system for the evaluation of notable bird observations, which in turn supported growth of community knowledge in identification criteria and patterns of occurrence. This happened before the internet, before mobile phones, digital photography, and before large searchable databases of peer reviewed data like eBird existed. This historical context is essential: the conditions that made the OBRC effective in 1981 have changed, while the operations of the OBRC have remained the same.  

Modern bird discoveries are now often supported by high-quality digital media, instantaneous communication, more extensive comparative material, and are soon entered into publicly accessible databases. While social media and online platforms have expanded access to information, they have also created an environment where sustained analysis or preservation of valuable material is challenging at best. Notable discussion often occurs rapidly and informally, then disappears into the digital abyss.


What is the purpose of a bird records committee? 

The answer to this question, in my opinion, should be the core guiding principle on how bird record committees could or should evolve. I believe that the collection, review, publication and archiving of bird records was not the purpose of the OBRC, they were the actions which supported the true purpose, to increase our knowledge of the status of birds in Ontario and to establish standards of observation and reporting. 

In 1981 our community knowledge grew thanks to the actions of the OBRC. The annual report was full of information about unusual bird occurrences that might have otherwise been inaccessible. In 2026, a keen and proactive (often amateur) field ornithologist may not learn anything new within the pages of an OBRC annual report. While at face value this may not seem like a significant concern, it is an unfortunate outcome of stagnation. These particularly keen individuals are the ones most likely to advance our collective community knowledge in the future, but are now doing so outside of the OBRC, and perhaps outside the umbrella of the Ontario Field Ornithologists itself. 


What could, or should, change? 

The voting structure of a bird records committee was generally designed to handle written accounts. An independent first round of voting would prevent external influence and also to stop “groupthink” with the initial evaluation. These concerns now rarely apply to a modern bird record, where hundreds of photos may be widely published within hours of initial discovery and identifications are discussed in real time. Another core goal of the OBRC, to provide a means by which sight records can gain acceptance as valuable scientific data, is often now accomplished within minutes through an eBird submission. While there are a multitude of ways the process could change, I believe considering how best to once again increase our knowledge of the status of birds in Ontario, and to establish standards of observation and reporting, provides clarity around what should change. 


The OBSG Proposal

I have been working with the support of others on how best to shift away from a traditional records committee model toward a structure better aligned with how bird study, documentation, and collaboration now occur. Responsibilities within the group would be separated by function and would not concentrated within a small group of individuals. Instead of strictly casting doubt or rendering judgement, expert review should focus primarily on adding value to a given record through analysis of plumage, molt, age, subspecies, movements, timing, awareness of similar taxa, and other analogous details. This positive evaluation will tease out potential concerns or inconsistencies within a report as they arise, but when they do arise, they would be documented with clear justification for the observer (and community) to learn from. An open, collaborative approach to data collection and review only increases the value that could be added to a report, rather than restricting input or collaboration, which was necessary in the era of written reports. This has another significant potential benefit; no individual or small group of individuals would be able to wield undue influence or control of the decisions of a bird records committee that prioritizes positive and defensible input. Anyone with relevant information to contribute would be able to participate

It should be noted that this can occur while maintaining the historical core actions of a bird records committee, such as the collection, publication and archival of material. Ideally, supporting the outcomes of competitive bird listing would be a positive side effect of our study, rather than the leading justification for the review of reports. 


Where do we go next?

Given the scattershot approach to bird study in the modern era, I believe it is time to reprioritize the production of durable and citable outputs, which add value to our collective knowledge. The success of any significant changes will still rely on volunteer support. Bird study and durable outputs are often not inherently suited to modern social media algorithms, and it may not ultimately be wise to compete for attention or engagement in that space. 

While data shows a steady decline in support from both the general birding community and among past OBRC members, presenting this data would not alter the fact that change in long-standing institutions is often difficult, particularly when existing systems were built and maintained by committed volunteers. Offering personal examples of concerns may appear selfish in nature. Highlighting impersonal issues may also be viewed as criticism of specific individuals who were involved in a given event. 

The OBRC is considered the raison d'être of the Ontario Field Ornithologists by many founding members. Ultimately, this conversation needs to shift from if change is necessary, to how change can be implemented, should proactive, amateur field ornithology will continue to be a part of the Ontario Field Ornithologists in the future. 


---










Figure 1. Black Swift. Point Pelee National Park, Ontario. May 17, 2009. This observation was reviewed and accepted by the Ontario Bird Records Committee and appears in eBird outputs. Neither approach addresses the question if this bird hails from the western North American population or the Caribbean population. 

---










Figure 2. Carolina Chickadee. Point Pelee National Park, Ontario. May 13, 2013. An account of this record was published in Ontario Birds (Holden and Bell 2016), not through any initiative of the OBRC, but through an independent effort to share the identification process with Ontario birders, with the hope that future records may materialize.

Holden, B.R. and D.M. Bell. 2016. Carolina Chickadee: Second record for Ontario and Canada. Ontario Birds, 34(1): 2–11

---


















Figure 3. Possible Chihuahuan Meadowlark. Point Pelee National Park, Ontario. April 25, 2016. When observers no longer see tangible value in supporting a bird records committee, they may stop submitting material or supporting the process. Despite this bird receiving strong  support from noted experts as a potential first record for Canada, it has not been submitted to the OBRC or published in Ontario Birds.


Monday, October 19, 2026

How it could be. Plegadis Ibis edition.

 

One of the more surprising things that arose when trying to encourage my local BRC to modernize (along with the parent org), was how forcefully the Status Quo Preservation Society proclaimed  "that everything is actually fine, and that there is no evidence to suggest that everything isn't already perfect". 

In reality, I didn't think it would be fun (or nice) to highlight specific issues. At the time. 



May 2005. Point Pelee Birding Area. 


Thankfully there was a group of seven experts, who in the winter of 2005-2006, each independently voted to confirm that the above bird was, in fact, a Glossy Ibis. Wait, it wasn't reviewed in time for the 2005 report (published in late August 2006). It was actually reviewed in the winter of 2006-2007 so it took ~28 months before it was finally memorialized in print by the OBRC. 


Fast forward to October 17, 2026. Quinten Wiegersma posts in the Great Lakes Bird Study Group discord... 

First winter Glossy/White-faced Ibis Identification ?

To shorten as much as possible. He notes that publications often note young plegadis ibis are unidentifiable in their first fall. Several recent records in Ontario are noted (or eBird accepted) as Glossy Ibis. Birders DO note features they use to separate some individuals at this time of year, but he's unaware of instances where these ID criteria have been published. He also notes how the status of White-faced Ibis has been changing over the last 20 years, and that hybrids may be increasing. 

--- 

Wouldn't it be interesting if the Ontario birding community, or dare I say, the OBRC - had provided some valuable insights on this identification question over the past ~45 years? 

Glossy Ibis is no longer a review species - given the prevailing sentiment that the OBRC might become relevant again, if only there were less records to review. We now have an eBird database with apparent Glossy Ibis accepted as White-faced and apparent White-faced Ibis accepted as Glossy. Interestingly that second example was actually rejected as Glossy Ibis by the OBRC (but accepted as "plegadis" ibis... I guess that's the value of being an Ontario-wide ebird reviewer...). I won't get into the handful of accepted Glossy/White-faced Ibis records that can be identified to species... 

During my time on the OBRC, we had a Glossy Ibis report that seemed like a possible hybrid, but the current chair of the SQPS pushed a rather interesting take. Just accept it as a "plegadis ibis" which, technically, would include a hybrid. Therefore we could just ignore the question and move on. Field ornithology at its finest. 

---


At the time of writing, Quinten's excellent question has solicited a grand total of three "fire" emoticons and no written responses. I'm no ibis expert, but I could respond with my impressions, in the hopes that the conversation actually kicks off - or even that someone else might jump at the opportunity to highlight if something I said was incorrect. While the GLBSG has received some solid praise, I really thought it was the lowest rung of a ladder our community could climb. Responses on discord are eventually lost to the bowels of the internet.

Unfortunately OFO and the OBRC continue to party like it's 1999, and our provincial "birding" community is using an alternate discord server (OBA) that only cares about listing. I'll get into those more in the future, but for now, I just wish there was some organized institutional effort to actually promote field ornithology and the sharing of experience & expertise. 

Advanced knowledge becomes general knowledge when given the time to grow. In the modern world, we have lost meaningful learning for quick hits of random trivia to distract our brains. I really don't mind if other people aren't interested in these topics. The issue is the swaths of the community (the SQPS, half of the OFO board, the OBA moderators, etc.) are going out of their way to squash our interest in field ornithology. Our, as in, the small subset of us who enjoy the learning & study parts of birding. 



Saturday, October 17, 2026

Kirtland’s Warbler Consuming Ants at Point Pelee (2018 Note)


RIP Michigan Birds & Natural History News...  I wrote this short note for the journal, that was published in 2018: 

Holden, B.R. 2018. Kirtland’s warbler consuming ants during migration in Ontario. Michigan Birds and Natural History. 25(3): 172–174


--- 


Figure 1. Female Kirtland's Warbler actively foraging on ants


At 0900 on 18 May 2013 my Father and I were birding along the west beach footpath of Point Pelee National Park (Ontario, Canada) when an alternate (Humphrey and Parkes 1959) female Kirtland’s Warbler (Setophaga kirtlandii) caught our eyes. We secured record photographs and subsequently reported the sighting to the Ontbirds listserv, which allowed many other observers to enjoy the sighting. The habitat was that of a westerly facing beach dune community, notable with scattered Juniperus species. The bird was present in the same general area for the remainder of the day allowing us to return in the evening to obtain additional photographs. Known for their accommodating nature (Bocetti et al.), I was able to obtain a number of detailed images with a Canon 1DM4 DSLR and 600mm lens. Review of these images, both in the field and afterwards, showed that the bird was catching and consuming ants (Order: Hymenpotera) (Figures 1,2).

While the order is known to account for a sizeable portion of the species diet on the breeding grounds (Deloria-Scheffield et al. 2001) seemingly little has been published on migrant individuals at stopover locations; presumably due to the general scarcity of observations and subsequent inability to complete any detailed study.

The Kirtland’s Warbler is a rare but regular migrant in Ontario with 75 records accepted by the Ontario Bird Records Committee through 2016 (Burrell et al. 2016), with this individual representing the 58th (Holden 2014). The majority of observations have occurred in the extreme south-west portion of the province during spring migration, presumably on route to the species stronghold in the lower peninsula of Michigan (Probst 1991). Recent records well east in Ontario may be attributed to isolated breeding populations in Ontario, such as Renfrew County first discovered in 2006 (Richard 2008); which has been active every year thereafter (Richard 2013), as well as other unpublished occurrences. It is hoped that this note and associated images will shed a small amount of light on the species diet during at a stopover site during migration, a poorly known period of its life cycle.




Figure 2. Kirtland's Warbler eyeing up ants on a small trunk


Literature Cited

Bocetti, C.I., Donner D.M. and H.F. Mayfield. Kirtland’s Warbler (Setophaga kirtlandii), The Birds of North America Online (A. Poole, ED.). Ithaca: Cornell Lab of Ornithology; Retrieved from the birds of North America Online: http://bna.birds.cornell.edu/bna/species/019doi:10.2173/bna.19

Burrell M.V.A., Charlton B.N. and K.G.D. Burrell. 2017. Ontario Bird Records Committee Report for 2016. Ontario Birds 34(2):58-85.

Deloria-Sheffield C.M., Millenbah, K.F., Bocetti, C.I., Sykes Jr., P.W. and C.B. Kepler. 2001. Kirtland’s Warbler Diet as Determined Through Fecal Analysis. Wilson Bulletin

Holden, B.R. 2014. Ontario Bird Records Committee Report for 2014. Ontario Birds 32(2):54-81.

Humphrey, P.S. and K.C. Parkes. 1959. An approach to the study of moots and plumages. Auk 76:1-31.

Probstm J.R. 1991. Kirtland’s Warbler. In: The Atlas of Breeding Birds of Michigan (R. Brewer, G. McPeek, and R. Adams Jr., Eds.), Michigan State University Press, East Lansing, Michigan, USA. pp. 414-417.

Richard, T. 2013. Seven Years Later: Kirtland’s Warbler at Garrison Petawawa, 2006-2013. Ontario Birds 31(3):148-159.

Richard, T. 2008. Confirmed Occurrence and Nesting of the Kirtland’s Warbler at CFP Petawawa, Ontario: A First for Canada. Ontario Birds 26(1)2-15.

Tuesday, October 13, 2026

A funny thing happened on the way to ... Michigan Birds and Natural History News

 

Another fun thing that I wrote... That wasn't published... But not due to any bizarre internal politics (this time)...  Here is what followed; a "letter to the editors" or "commentary" to Michigan Birds and Natural History News: 

-------------


Regarding a reported Slaty-backed Gull from Whitefish Point, Chippewa, Michigan from May 19-20, 2017 and the role of Bird Records Committees 



Figure 1. Slaty-backed Gull at Whitefish Point, May 19, 2026. Photo by Skye Haas. 


This note pertains to a reported adult Slaty-backed Gull (Larus schistisagus) from Whitefish Point, Chippewa, Michigan from May 19-20, 2017. While conducting a review of available media of Slaty-backed Gull from the Great Lakes region, I was surprised that photos of this individual were unavailable for retrieval on the eBird.org website (eBird). Further investigation revealed that the record had been “rejected” by the Michigan Bird Records Committee (MBRC) which was the trigger for their suppression from the public output of eBird. 

This discovery led to a slight detour in my undertaking. I then sought out the original photos as well as the rationale provided for why the record was rejected. This ultimately led to further reflection on the role and intent of bird record committees, including my limited experience with the MBRC and my extensive experience with the Ontario Bird Records Committee (OBRC) of my home province.
 
Observer notes from the initial date of observation are as follows: 

Adult bird. Observed in small flock of gulls bathing and loafing in pools at tip of Whitefish Point. Immediately stood out as being intermediate in size between LBBG &GBBG. Structure was readily apparent with SBGU displaying a projecting "goose-like" breast, rounded head and thin THGU-like bill structure. Legs a deep bubblegum pink, a stronger color than the GBBG and HERG it was observed with. Substantially wide white tertial skirt, and in flight the white trailing edge of the wing was noticeably wider than the other gull spp present. Subterminal white spots were not the boldest marked I've seen on the species, but still present and observed in photos. Observed in both photos and through scope looks was the reduced black on the upper outer primaries, with the black restricted to the outer webs of the primaries creating a Venetian blind look ala THGU. Also noticed in both the field and from photos was the reduced black on underwing as compared to LBBG or GBBG.



Figure 2. Photo by Skye Haas. 

 
The reasoning provided to the observers regarding the rejection of the May 19-20, 2017 Slaty-backed Gull is as follows: 

Slaty-backed Gull 2017-0480-02 (initial vote: 5-2)
Those voting to reject based their concerns on traits viewed in the photographs, namely that they thought the underwing pattern was too pale, the tongues were too narrow, and that the secondary trailing edge was not thick enough and appeared uniform with the primary trailing edge. Their thinking was that maybe one of these features is ok for a pure Slaty-backed but certainly not all of them. One member thought that the legs seemed long for this species. Those present who had voted to accept recognized these concerns but were undecided as to how they would vote the next time.



Figure 3. Photo: Steve Kolbe. 


These comments revived feelings of my own experiences with the OBRC on unrelated observations. I provide my thoughts not as a direct critique of the MBRC or the members of the 2017 committee, but as a representative example on how these decisions may affect the reporting observer(s) of a rare bird, the birding community and the ability for a records committee to achieve their stated objectives. 

To start, the first sentence raises concern. “Those voting to reject based their concerns on traits viewed in the photographs…”. There is a growing trend for validators of bird records to formulate their opinions strictly on available media, rejecting the field notes and particularly field experience of those taking the time to submit a report. While I cannot provide any basis on the potential for photographs to be misleading, observers to make mistakes, and/or the greater likelihood of either scenario unfolding – this approach ultimately does work to discredit the observer. This may lead to a reluctance from observers to take field notes or to provide text with their submissions to a records committee at all. 

Items regarding observed field marks raise further concern, specifically the “concerning traits” noticed by dissenting MBRC members, that the: 
- “the underwing pattern was too pale”; 
- “the secondary trailing edge was not thick enough”; and, 
- “the secondary trailing edge … appeared uniform with the primary trailing edge”. 

These comments are representative of a growing problem where validators of bird records may be searching for justification around the rejection of a record which leads to a subsequent explanation that is not necessarily rooted in fact or reality. I am of the opinion that each one of these traits, as shown in Figures 1, 2, and 3 respectively, are comfortably within the expected appearance of an adult Slaty-backed Gull. The underwing pattern shows the expected darker colouration on the underside of the primaries and secondaries (Figure 3), the secondary trailing edge is notably thick (Figures 2 and 3), and the trailing edge of the secondaries and primaries is not uniform (Figure 3). Using proper fieldmarks as justification for the rejection of a record surely leads to dissatisfaction and would lead to a reluctance from observers to make future submissions to a records committee. 

Finally, I was intrigued by this last perceived issue with the identification:
- “One member thought that the legs seemed long for this species”.

This brings forward another growing concern that I have with the validation of bird records, the notion that an observer must somehow be cognizant of, or dare I say omnipotent, in order to predict the potential concerns a reviewer may have with a bird record. I will boast that there may be few other observers in the Great Lakes region that enjoy gull study as I do, yet I would not have considered discussing the length of the legs for a potential SBAG. In hindsight, an observer might note that the apparent length of the legs may be affected by warmer weather conditions in May. Or perhaps the belly of the bird was slim due to illness or the pressures of long northward flights in spring migration? Alas, this feedback is only received following the initial rejection of a record – which as noted, is likely to have had a detrimental effect on the desire for an observer to bother supporting a records committee in the future. 

Many committees are adequately serving community members who are focused on competitive bird-listing endeavors, capturing records that are well observed and widely documented. Yet I would note that modern websites such as eBird would be similarly capable of similar undertakings if allowed to conduct their own validations outside of committee decisions. I would therefore like to encourage records committees and their members to consider how these decisions may be working against their goals to turn these records into valuable scientific data. Suppression of this Slaty-backed Gull observation, and similar records, would only reduce our ability to know the limits of occurrence of this species within the Great Lakes region. This effect is compounded when the most proactive members of the bird watching community, those who push to make new discoveries regarding bird identification and distribution, become disenfranchised with the process and have subsequent documentation that never reaches a records committee in the first place. 

In their foundations, these committees provided some of the best possible means to compile and disseminate information about vagrant bird identification and distribution given the technology available at the time. If the MBRC or other committees viewed their modern undertakings through this lens, how to best enhance the scientific value of our hobby through the sharing of knowledge, I suspect there would be improvements that can arise to the betterment of our community as a whole. 

(Submitted Aug 2025)




-------------

Maybe a bit sassy or self-centered on my part... But I sent it in anyways... And then I never heard back! 

I figured it was the standard issue regarding the fear of critique or potential change/improvement... Instead, it was because the journal had folded! At the time, the website was still up and the email for submissions as still posted - but the journal had gone under a few years previously. Ouch. 

There were a few other events beyond this instance that eventually convinced me to try to support/improve the process at home (in Ontario)... I'll be randomly sharing them here as time allows.