Sharing something that was published in the Ontario Birds journal, during my ill-fated attempt to bring some "field ornithology" back to the Ontario Field Ornithologists...
Normally I would post a link to the article, but OFO has recently taken the short-sighted approach of pay-walling the most recent issues... Yes, it will be visible online a year after it comes out.. And yes, you can now get a "free" membership with OFO - but no one is going to sign up just to read a note on a hybrid gull.
Instead, I'm copying and pasting this into a blog...
Another small (sad) example of stagnation - due to the board's refusal to modernize - which has pushed our most active birders into "other" spaces (blogs, discord groups), ultimately splitting the community a little bit more and reducing the core "purpose" of OFO itself.
But I digress..
-----
An Apparent American Herring Gull x Glaucous-winged Gull Hybrid from Wheatley, Ontario with Commentary on Modern Identification Challenges for Field Ornithologists
Holden, B.R., 2026. An apparent American Herring Gull x Glaucous-winged Gull hybrid at Wheatley, Ontario with commentary on modern identification challenges for field ornithologists. Ontario Birds 44(1):9-17
On 26 April 2022, I observed an unusual large gull (Larus sp.) at Wheatley Harbour in Chatham-Kent County, Ontario. I had spent the morning a short distance to the west, at the end of Zion Road where it meets Lake Erie, watching for potential “reverse migrants”: birds retreating south following a strong shift from seasonally warm air to seasonally cool air. This dynamic juxtaposition of weather may produce notable migratory movements or vagrancy locally and can be more climatologically likely at this time of year. That is to say, while you are never quite sure what you might see during a day of birding, I was not entirely surprised to spot birds like Baltimore Oriole (Icterus galbula), Cape May Warbler (Setophaga tigrine), and Northern Parula (Setophaga americana) flying down the shoreline while an adult Thayer’s Iceland Gull (L. glaucoides thayeri) and an adult American Herring Gull (L. smithsonianus) x Glaucous Gull (L. hyperboreus) hybrid (aka “Nelson’s” Gull) were foraging behind active fishing operations offshore (see Holden 2022a). It was the observations of these arctic gulls that encouraged me to visit Wheatley Harbour after the morning flight movement had waned.
Figure 1. Apparent near-adult Glaucous-winged Gull x
American Herring Gull hybrid (i.e., Cook Inlet Gull) from Wheatley, Ontario on
April 26, 2022. Photo by Brandon Holden.
Preliminary Study
After securing my first flight images of the bird, I reviewed one image of the primary pattern, which initially set my identification process astray (see Figure 2). This one image showed the dark primary markings extending up to the base of the feathers from P10 through P7, recalling the primary pattern shown by Western Gull (L. occidentalis). This made for an initial assumption that the bird may be a hybrid between Western Gull and Glaucous-winged Gull (i.e., an “Olympic Gull”).
Figure 2. Apparent near-adult Glaucous-winged x American Herring Gull hybrid from Wheatley, Ontario on April 26, 2022. Photo by Brandon Holden. Note how in this angle, there appears to be extensive and high reaching dark markings on the outer primaries (i.e., P10 through P7) which may recall the pattern shown by Western Gull.
It wasn’t until later, with the full suite of images available to review on a computer, that it became apparent that the black primary markings were largely concentrated on the outer webs of each feather (see Figures 3 and 4) along with a “string of pearls” (i.e., white crescents above the black terminal band on the outer primaries). This was therefore not supportive of Western Gull as the other potential parent species but also seemed to be at odds with perhaps the most likely or expected explanation, a Glaucous-winged Gull x American Herring Gull hybrid (i.e., a “Cook Inlet Gull”). I have been fortunate to observe thousands of individuals of this hybrid combination during nearshore marine surveys around Prince Rupert, British Columbia and I could not recall observing such an extreme primary pattern as shown by the subject bird (see Figure 5).
Figures 3 and 4. Apparent near-adult Glaucous-winged Gull x
American Herring Gull from Wheatley, Ontario on Apr 26, 2022. Photo by Brandon
Holden. Note the primary pattern, with dark gray to blackish markings extending
down the outer webs of the outer primaries, along with large primary mirrors
and a “string of pearls” (white markings above the dark terminal band) on the 5th
through 8th primary. Darker markings on the underwing are also
visible, indicating a near-adult plumage.
The heavy structure of the bird, the extensive string of pearls, and the "venetian blind" effect to the primary markings provided some reason to consider a Glaucous-winged Gull hybrid with Slaty-backed Gull (L. schistisagus), also known as the “Commander Gull”. While this combination is presumably very rare anywhere in North America, some media available in the Macaulay Library and on iNaturalist.org appeared to look surprisingly similar to the subject bird (see Figure 6). Yet, the combination of a reasonably pale mantle on the Wheatley bird and the extreme unlikeliness of a Commander Gull reaching the Great Lakes called for a greater effort in my research.
Commander Gull vs. Cook Inlet Gull
Despite the primary pattern, I still felt that a Cook Inlet Gull may be a reasonable explanation for the appearance of the subject bird. Hybrids from the Gulf of Alaska, while common in their home range, may not be an ideal source population for the potential occurrence of this hybrid in Ontario. I speculated that a Glaucous-winged Gull at the northern or northeastern limits of the species range may well hybridize with a more northerly or arctic nesting American Herring Gull, each showing subtle regional variation when compared to the more commonly observed hybrids originating further south or west. They may also be more likely to reach the Great Lakes due to their longer overland migration and potential for prevailing fall and winter winds to push them south and east.
A more focused search of available media quickly added support to this theory. A Cook Inlet Gull documented by Cameron Eckert from Whitehorse, Yukon on 11 Apr 2016 showed a similar venetian blind pattern to the dark primary markings combined with the white “string of pearls” (see Figure 7) among other notable individuals. Interestingly, a vagrant Glaucous-winged Gull from Illinois in January 2024 showed a similar underlying primary pattern, with the venetian blind distribution and extensive string-of-pearls (see Figure 8). This pattern would again seem extreme when compared to apparently “pure” Glaucous-winged Gulls from the Gulf of Alaska (see Figure 9).
Figure 7. Adult Glaucous-winged Gull x American Herring Gull
from Whitehorse, Yukon on 11 April 2016. Photo by Cameron Eckert. Note the
extensive white markings in the outer primary pattern.
Figure 8. Adult Glaucous-winged Gull from Lake County,
Illinois on 22 January 2024. Photo by Woody Goss. Note the “string of pearls”
pattern showing in the outer primaries.
Figure 9. Adult Glaucous-winged Gull from offshore Prince
Rupert, British Columbia on December 4, 2013. Photo by Brandon Holden.
While confidently identifying hybrid gulls may ultimately be an exercise in guesswork and assumptions, it felt prudent to now consider the identification of the Wheatley bird as a Glaucous-winged x American Herring Gull, the Cook Inlet Gull, despite not strongly resembling the widespread examples of this hybrid from the Gulf of Alaska. Further, any potential occurrence of Commander Gull locally might be expected show a mantle tone distinctly darker than an American Herring Gull.
Discussion
The involvement of Glaucous-winged Gull as a parent of the subject bird was judged mainly from its general size and shape; however, it is very hard to adequately capture these traits in photos or to clearly describe them in text. Early commentary from other gull enthusiasts expressed doubt that a more common species, such as a “Thayer’s” Iceland Gull, could be confidently eliminated. I later noticed that I had fortuitously captured several photos of the subject bird in flight in close proximity to an American Herring Gull, which provides a clear point of reference to judge size and shape (see Figures 10, 11, and 12). This supported my field impression, but it also highlighted what I perceive to be a growing problem in bird study: a fortunate moment was needed to make the bird adequately documentable to external experts who focus only on photographic study. The account of an experienced field observer is often ignored, and instead the record may only “survive” if a lucky situation arises when obtaining media documentation. While higher quality media is always valuable, expecting all observations to occur with ideal angles, lighting, or postures - to validate an unusual sighting - feels like an unreasonable expectation that would ultimately hamper future study and learning.
Figures 10, 11 and 12. Apparent near-adult Glaucous-winged
Gull x American Herring Gull hybrid, in close proximity to a third cycle
American Herring Gull, from Wheatley, Ontario on 26 April 2022. Photos by
Brandon Holden. Note the broad wings and bulky proportions of the hybrid gull
in direct comparison to the American Herring Gull.
Much of my research regarding the Wheatley bird focused on what I perceived to be an atypical expression in the primary pattern. Popular reference material, such as Gulls of the Americas (Howell and Dunn 2007) or The Gull Guide (Ayyash 2024), may have ultimately shed light on the potential variability of Cook Inlet hybrids, yet there are limits to how much information can be presented in the text, and how many potential variations can be shown as printed media. These guides show a combined 59 images of Glaucous-winged x American Herring Gull hybrids, representing both perched and flight images of all age classes. While the Macaulay Library does not apply the same vetting standards as formal publications, and would require more caution as a reference source, there are over seven thousand reference photos of this hybrid available for study (eBird 2026). Therefore, I propose that while it is important to utilize expert opinion and popular reference materials when opportunity arises, they should not immediately override the research conducted by keen birders regarding an atypical bird observation.
Conclusion
While the identity of this gull may be of interest to those engaged in bird study, I also hope this article works to encourage observers to push analytical boundaries, question established norms and undertake independent research when presented with a challenging observation. I believe that the identification of some unusual or vagrant birds will improve with a broader recognition that regional variation can influence plumage variation and/or molt timing. Rigid expectations, based on a specific reference population or a limited set of published images, risk obscuring atypical yet legitimate expressions of variation. Expert opinions, while valid, may be overly cautious, quick to dismiss, or rush judgement on images alone without appreciating observer input. This may inadvertently stifle meaningful discussion or even discourage further study. As a result, valid questions or interesting observations may be lost, not because they lack merit, but because they challenge familiar thinking or require notably more effort by eBird reviewers or bird records committees to fully evaluate.
This individual represents a rare occurrence of an apparent American Herring Gull x Glaucous-winged Gull hybrid in Ontario, well east of the typical hybrid zone in western North America. It is also worth noting that there are previous reports of putative Glaucous-winged Gull x American Herring Gull hybrids from Ontario and nearby US states but given that hybrid gulls do not “count” on the lists of competitive birders, there is significantly less interest in their identification and these records may also have received less scrutiny for their validation. It is hoped that this article encourages others to undertake and enjoy detailed study of gulls.
Citations
Ayyash, A. 2024. The Gull Guide: North America. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ. 528 pp.
eBird. 2026. The Macaulay Library media search for Glaucous-winged Gull x American Herring Gull hybrids. Accessed by Brandon Holden on 5 February 2026.
Holden, 2022a. eBird checklist S108170512, accessed 3 February 2026. https://ebird.org/checklist/S108170512
Holden, 2022b. eBird checklist S108170016, accessed 3 February 2026. https://ebird.org/checklist/S108170016
Howell, S.N.G. and J. Dunn. 2007. Gulls of the Americas. Houghton, New York, New York. 516 pp.





No comments:
Post a Comment