Sunday, November 22, 2026

Video Overview: An apparent AHGU x GWGU from Wheatley (with commentary etc etc)

 

Testing something new / different... I posted the text of this article on Friday (link here).. A video overview of the article... 

Does it help (or at the very least, is it interesting) to have the same material covered twice? I know it's a pretty dull topic, which is part of the reason why I started with this one... Check it out here: 




I don't script the videos - so it's not perfectly clear - and I don't always hit all the points I intended to cover.. But it's easy, fast and fun! 



In a nutshell: 

  • Don't be turned off from doing your own research 
  • Don't be afraid to be "wrong" 
  • Modern bird documentation needs to evolve past the 1980's and 1990's approach of "how familiar are you with this bird?" ... "what binoculars were you using?" ... "what's your very incorrect guess about how far away you were?"... 
  • We need to stop assuming an expert that has spent a lot of time in Prince Rupert, BC knows what a vagrant Glaucous-winged Gull from Yukon looks like (or, for example, what a GWGU from Siberia might look like). 
    • I'm not saying to totally discount experts, but most BRC's and eBird reviewers just treat the same 2-3 people as infallible justices of the "bird identification supreme court". Which isn't a good thing for the growth of our niche interests in this hobby... 
  • Publishing an article/note may be one the few ways to preserve an idea / record / research ... compared to it being buried and lost on the "facebook gull group" or the local discord group.
    • If we put more time / effort into publishing, we wouldn't feel compelled to be on facebook all of the time - just in case we missed an interesting identification discussion... Less screen time, more outside birding time.. Ya know?!
  • I'd love to see less emphasis on "THIS IS THE FIRST RECORD" for publications as well (esp. for things like weird hybrids or plumages that no one looks for) - it's fairly clear that the ON records of GWGUxAHGU on ebird aren't exactly reviewed to a high standard... But that's just me... 

Let me know what you think!






No comments:

Post a Comment